Mike asked Maddie what she thought I had told him and she said that I had told Mike something completely unrelated to the trail mix.
Mike told her that was not what my eyes had communicated at all. He said, "In fact, she told me that if I even think about stealing another piece she's going to smack my hand." Maddie said that wasn't true and looked at me. I told her it was absolutely true and it was exactly what I had told him "with my eyes".
She reiterated that we were weird.
Fast forward to this afternoon, Maddie asked if we could eat lunch downstairs and watch a movie. She looked at me first and I replied it was okay. At the same time she turned to look at Mike who was looking at me "talking to me" telling me he thought they'd be fine eating at the table first.
Maddie jumped in and said, "Don't EVEN start that eye talk again. Mom already said, 'Yes.'"